and you're saying that milton bradley, who has an .890 OPS the last 5 years, is one of those guys? the last time he had an OPS that low was 2004, and he was at the high end of that range, and was playing half his games in a pitcher's park (his road OPS was .823). wrong. his K-rate is about the same as mark teixeira or bobby abreu, do you think those guys were decent hitters for average? a guy like jack cust or adam dunn strikes out too much to hit for a high average; a guy who strikes out in 18% of his ABs can easily hit .275-.300. well, he gets on base a lot more than cuddyer, and his career EqA is 10 points higher than cuddyer, and that's just his career numbers - if you use his last 5 years, which are a lot more representative of how he's likely to perform the next 2-3 years than his career numbers, it's probably more like 25 points. so i'd say he's quite a bit better. and he gets hurt more.