If Hawpe didn't sit so often against LHPs, that OPS wouldn't be so impressive: Hawpe career vs. RHP - 921 PA, 30 HR, .284/.372/.473 Hawpe career vs. LHP - 123 PA, 4 HR, .227/.309/.400 For comparison's sake: Jones career vs. RHP - 3371 PA, 138 HR, .295/.343/.493 Jones career vs. LHP - 993 PA, 21 HR, .228/.275/.350 I'd certainly rather have Hawpe than Jones. I can't imagine prefering Hawpe to Soriano, though, unless you actively root for a low payroll: Hawpe PA, OPS+ 2004, age 25 - 118, 72 2005, age 26 - 351, 88 2006, age 27 - 575, 122 Soriano PA, OPS+ 2001, age 25 - 614, 92 2002, age 26 - 741, 131 2003, age 27 - 734, 128 2004, age 28 - 658, 98 2005, age 29 - 682, 110 2006, age 30 - 728, 132