Roberto Alomar Bert Blyleven Andre Dawson Barry Larkin Mark McGwire Tim Raines Alan Trammell Those would be my votes. Larkin and Trammell are borderline for me. Someone would have to explain to me why they'd vote for one, but not the other. If you put Dawson in a Red Sox or Yankees uniform for any significant amount of time, he's not only a first ballot Hall of Famer, he'd be talked of as one of the great legends of the game. Despite playing his best seasons in Montreal, Rookie of the Year, MVP, runner up twice, another top 10 finish, 8 all-stars, 8 GG's. 438 pre-steroid home runs. A reputation for being, not only a great competitor and team mate, but also an all-around nice guy... The list of eligible players with more hits than Andre Dawson who are not in the HoF are as follows: Harold Baines. Of course Dawson was, in addition to being a comparable offensive player to Baines, a very good base-stealer and an elite outfielder, two things that Baines was definitely not. If someone wanted to argue with me that Morris should be in, I could probably be convinced. As much of a homer as I am for him, I just can't quite pull the trigger on Lee Smith. Compare his numbers to Hoffman, Rivera, or Wagner, and he just doesn't measure up.