I don't see how the pythag says anything about the offense over/underachieving. It tells you if the team is underachieving given the ability it shows over a given season to score and prevent runs in terms of wins, but it does nothing to tell you if players x, y, and z are performing over/under expectations. That said, outside of SS, I don't think this lineup is overachieving that much. We've got a good platoon going in CF. Hopefully, Edmonds picks it back up, but, yea, that's a sort of questionable area in our lineup too. Like UM said, though, once the playoffs roll around, it doesn't really matter. Either the team is going to be hot and tear through the playoffs like the 05 white sox, or it's not.