Jump to content
North Side Baseball

raw

Community Moderator
  • Posts

    5,716
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    7

 Content Type 

Profiles

Chicago Cubs Videos

Chicago Cubs Trade & Free Agent Rumors

2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospect Rankings

Chicago Cubs News, Rumors & Analysis

2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Chicago Cubs Fan Guides & Resources

2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Blogs

Events

Forums

Store

Gallery

Everything posted by raw

  1. Maybe I’ve read too many “a league source says” stories but the perception out there seems to be that Smith is a very good, not great player at a non-premium position. It would be beneficial for him to prove that he is great going into FA or a franchise tag. not saying that will happen with a guy who is said to have maturity issues and is operating without the guidance of an agent but it makes all the sense in the world for him to ball out. It does, and I'm sure when he's in there, he'll play well. But this is a guy that hasn't always made the best decisions. He had the mysterious absence for a game a few years ago. He's now held out on 2 different occasions. I just worry about what happens Week 10 when this team is 3-6 and he has an annoyance with an ankle or something. It's probably not going to be something that can be proven, if he's smart about it (not a guarantee). I just don't see a good ending. I don't see him playing great and then the Bears changing their offer to something he'd agree too. I don't see him caving on taking the Bears offer. Most likely scenario is he walks or is tagged after the season, which starts this process all over again. And if he walks, it'll likely be for nothing as the Bears will certainly spend money bringing in guys to wipe his comp pick away.
  2. Yeah, my issue is a repeat of last year with Robinson. Robinson was unhappy with contract and we saw him quitting on routes, quitting on blocks, take like 4 weeks to return from a hamstring injury that was day-to-day (granted, can't proved he dogged it). Don't see too many players hold out/in for a new contract, publicly ask for a trade, not get either, and still play 100% of the games at 100% of his abilities. Sure there have been players who have held out before, come back without being paid and play well. There have been players ask for a trade, get paid and then play well. But this isn't a franchise tag thing. Smith isn't getting paid the average of the top 5 at his position. He's getting 9M when his peers are getting more than double that. These things don't typically end well.
  3. Said they basically just missed it. Same problem, different people. Don't the Bears have a guy for this? That guy probably sucks. I assume it would be a different guy, but I'm pretty sure the guy Nagy had on reviews was terrible.
  4. I thought the first team OL was actually solid last night. Stats show Fields was pressured 4 times on 8 drop backs 1- TE screen to Kmet (12 yards). IDK if this counts as a pressure, but it's a screen. That's how they work. 2- Incomplete dump off to Kmet. The OL was perfect on this play. Pressure came from blitzer who blew thru Herbert 3- Fields scramble (1 yard). Pocket was actually clean. He could have stepped up to throw, but just kept running. (Jenkins gets beat, but does maintain his block and drives the guy WAY up field). 4- Dump off to Herbert (4 yards). No pressure 5- Rollout to Kmet (19 yards). I don't think this would count as a pressure. 6- WR screen to Mooney (5 yards). No pressure 7- Rollout incomplete in end zone. This probably counts as pressure too. But it was a designed rollout and Fields had several seconds to throw, nobody open (though a better throw may get that TD to Mooney). This isn't on the OL as he was near the sidelines 8- Dump off to Herbert (-2 yards). Jenkins gets beat pretty bad, and there is a free (delayed) blitzer off the edge. I'm guessing plays 1, 2, 7 and 8 are being counted as Fields being pressured. Only 1 of these are on the OL. They weren't perfect by any means, but they were better than 50% pressure rate suggests.
  5. The Bears #1 offense has scored 1 TD in preseason since 2017. Granted that includes no preseason in 2020 and Nagy famously not playing starters much despite them needing the reps for most of his tenure.....but it's not like that bleeds into the regular season or anything. And I know the plan is to play the starters only 6-10 snaps (was also called 1-2 drives, which LOL almost feels like planning two 3 and outs), but it would be really nice if the Bears #1 offense did something good in the first series. I know last week was nationally televised, but it was also NFL Network, and at 1 EST on a summer Saturday. Would be cool once to show the world that Fields isn't in a dire situation. Especially being on ESPN and all their talking heads are convinced the Bears are easily going to be the worst team in football. Not that they are wrong for believing that or that the offense scoring means this is a top unit, but it would be nice to have some positives to talk about a Bears offense at the proverbial Friday morning water cooler.
  6. Getsy today said that there was only 1 play from Fields that he didn't like, and that was the play he should have drawn a late hit call. Said he scrambled too soon when his 2nd read was open. But otherwise a strong performance. I'll buy that. Even that sack by Jones, like I said, I think he could have gotten the ball out to Mooney like right when he planted his back foot. And maybe he could have stepped up, but that would have required quite the effort and anticipation from anyone, especially a QB in like the 3rd week of a new offense. The late hit play, there wasn't really any pressure, and I would have liked for him to throw that ball into the seats. Actually was a counted as a sack because he started his slide 1/2 yard behind the LOS.
  7. IDK if it's going thru progressions too quickly or not having that anticipation yet. Like there are times you gotta see the defender flat footed and know know your WR is going to be able to give you the space to fit that ball in. Like on the sack, sure it was WAY quicker than you want pressure, but Fields had Mooney open right away with a pick happening. He could have gotten that ball out right away. Granted, I don't think he could have anticipated that pressure right away, but then he missed the chance to step up in the pocket and make another throw. Part of it is being in a new offense (again). But some of that is just his game. He likes to see it open before he throws it. To be fair, it's fine if he doesn't ever get the anticipation down (Cutler wasn't great at it, Watson isn't great at it). But that could be the difference between being a really good QB and being a Rodgers/Brady level QB. The 2 long completions were really nice though. The one to Mooney was anticipation, but that's clearly designed to go to him. Great placement on that ball as well. The one to Sharpe was him recognizing the blitz and putting the ball only where his guy could catch it. Literally perfect ball placement.
  8. They were pretty vanilla with Fields in there. With Siemien and Peterman, I think they showed much more of what the offense will look like. Seemed like pretty basic stuff with Fields....handoff if under C, pass if in gun. There were screens, endarounds and actual passing concepts called (Dazz TD prime example). I would have loved to see Fields running some of that stuff, but I get why they didn't. And until proven otherwise, I'll assume it's purposeful instead of Nagy setting Justin up to fail.
  9. So this is fun. Playing a little hardball it seems. The only reasons to take him off of PUP, since he's not actually injured (in order of least likely): 1. They are close to a long-term extension 2. Imminent trade, though IDK if a player has to be off PUP before traded. I think the new team would take him off PUP. 3. They are putting the pressure on him to start practicing or he will get fined for every day he misses. This probably can't possibly end well could it?
  10. Eh. "Blowing all the cap" isn't even a thought. The Bears will have like 100Mil in cap next year. And based on the spending for this year, they are going to be hard pressed to even reach that number, unless they spend stupidly. Mack is a terrible comparison because of age, his already high salary, and the fact that trading him was partly in response to a lack of draft picks in the current year. Smith doesn't have an age argument, the high salary would be in the future which right now has no other high salary players (once Jackson, Quinn and Whitehair are gone likely after this year and before Mooney can potentially be signed). I get that off ball LB isn't a high impact position. And ideally, you'd only spend on QB, LT and truly the elites of the elite, but you can't make a habit of allowing 25 year old players, on a team devoid of young talent, to walk because he doesn't play your ideal position. And honestly, WLB is one of the positions (along with nickel and 3T) that Eberflus says are most important in his defense. Keep good, young players....when you don't have good, young players. I didn't love letting Daniels walk because you are almost certain to get older at the position and lose upside as well (Schofield much older, not as good run blocking). I definitely don't like letting Roquan go just to get worse at the position and also probably not getting much younger than 25, unless you spend an early draft pick on a position you in the same breath said isn't high impact, by allowing Roquan to walk.
  11. Velus Jones is going to die like midseason then.
  12. He's credited as a pretty revolutionary DC and won a title as a head coach. He's not the top of the top by any means but that seems pretty noncontroversial to me. By that standard, should a Dick Vermiel or Mike Holmgren be in? He didn’t even coach that long. LOL. Dick Vermeil is literally in THIS Hall of Fame class being inducted tomorrow. Holmgren will also be in. Also, Dungy coached for 28 years in the NFL, 13 as a head coach, and like was said he's the Cover 2 guy, has quite a large coaching tree at this point (including 2 of the best in Tomlin and Reich) and is the first black HC to win a Superbowl. His resume is slam dunk HOF worthy
  13. The weird thing to me is Poles seemingly sided with Jenkins on that dumb penalty last year that resulted in a fellow offensive lineman berating Jenkins for the time/place of the offense. Poles said he was more or less disgusted with a lineman telling another linemen not to be a redass idiot defending his QB. Maybe something is going on communication wise with Jenkins not quite getting the pseudo support followed up by demotion to potential swing tackle. Exactly the thought I had as well. I've always operated under the assumption that it was Jenkins and 4 other guys on the OL this year. On the field, he seems to embody the tough, athletic persona this team has preached about since these guys were hired. I guess off the field though, there are supposedly issues with his personality. Doesn't like being yelled at or challenged or some horsefeathers.
  14. Reports are saying that the team is actually more impressed by Fields than they expected to be. The Smith extension is interesting. While, I would have agreed with you completely a week ago, it seems like the "hold in" is happening because they are working on a deal. I don't know why Smith would show up at all if there was no progress on that front. He's being helpful in practice, Eberflus is speaking highly of him to reporters, and he was one of the few vets that showed up for all the offseason stuff (and he modeled the orange helmets damnit!). I also think Mooney is a guy they have identified as someone they really liked, even before camp. I could see him being traded as a big year means a 20M+ payday for him. And if they could get a 1st+ for him, I certainly wouldn't rule it out. Basically, I think this is an overly pessimistic view of the state of the franchise. That being said, you have every reason to feel this way. This has kinda been on the verge of a shitshow for the past 5 months.
  15. Let's also point out that this suspension comes with no fine somehow (other than game salaries lost). And luckily for Deshaun, the Browns structured his contract so that he only loses $243,500 of the $230,000,000 they are going to give him as a reward for sexually assaulting 25+ women. That's just barely over a 1/10 of a percent of his contract for those scoring at home, (against a woman's will).
  16. Kaplan patting himself on the back with the "I told ya so's"
  17. yep - if they add another receiver they'll accomplish basically everything we wanted them to during the offseason. I'm expecting a roughly Reiff-caliber add at WR (Will Fuller is still out there...). I don't think we've seen $ details on Schofield, but I believe Reiff ate up about half of the available funds I'm assuming N'Keal Harry was the big add at WR. Pretty recent move with similar timing to the 2 OL signings. Plus, I believe they are on the field Thursday, so probably everything else they add will be after cuts or injuries happen.
  18. Brisker signed. Roquan and Quinn in attendance today. Linemen signed. All is well at Halas Hall.
  19. And nobody knows if Robert Quinn is going to show up or not. I liked the Poles hire. I'm 100% in on giving him a chance. But this offseason has been a disasters no matter how optimistic you look at things going forward (and I'm pretty bullish on the direction in general). But if you're keeping score at home...... - Best player holding out - Little support of your potential franchise QB in terms of money spent or draft capital used - Fired the guy that helped hire him - 3 of the players he's added have been arrested, after a pretty clean track record from the previous regime. Lot of other stuff too. I'm pretty optimistic that the team can be more competitive than the masses think due to players buying into a new regime, an actual plan on offense, an elite talent at QB and overall an easy schedule. But it's tough to pull a decent season on the field out of a disasterous offseason off the field.
  20. Funny how good this is making Bears fans feel on social media. The Bears will likely have 3 below average players on the interior. But I guess it's better than 2 below average and 1 flat out liability. Schofield is a good pass blocker. Below average run blocker. Honestly, I feel like you can hide his run blocking if Patrick is good at C and your RT is a decent run blocker. Interesting here is this probably puts a position change for Jenkins or Borom out of the forefront and they are battling it out with the rookie Jones for the 2 OT spots. I know Jenkins was not their pick, but no way this regime can NOT start easily the highest picked (aka most talented) player on the line somewhere.
  21. This kinda makes the point. As a fan of a team you have to hope to be extremely fortunate with a draft pick, or you're at the whims of whatever a top player feels like doing for his next gig, sometimes both. For me at least it's difficult to be invested in a team that has so little autonomy relative to other sports in its ability to create a championship roster. I get that and mostly agree with it, at the same time it's the best league for its players. The challenge is for capital/management to build an environment where people want to stay and gravitate towards. I can see a situation in the near future where a team offers some small percentage of ownership to high-level influence players. N = 1 basketball is by far my son's favorite sport to watch on TV. That's what makes the NBA better than MLB, for one. NBA actually markets its players. MLB markets "the game". Trout might be the best baseball player of all time, he should be everywhere like LeBron is. And he plays in a huge market in LA, just like LeBron. I also think MLB has as much autonomy as the NBA for franchises to create championship rosters. Just like the NBA, your franchise has to be willing to pay the luxury tax. Obviously, players can't choose where they want while on a contract. And it takes more than 1-2 players to swing a 26 man roster instead of a 15, but MLB teams have just as much ability to spend like the Dodgers and Yankees. And nothing is stopping players from recruiting other big names the way the NFL and NBA do.
  22. I kinda agree. There's no battling for rebounds, no defense until the end of games. There's 3-point shots and then everyone gets back on defense, leaving uncontested rebounds for the defense (why you have guards getting double digit boards these days). But I think overall, the talent and athleticism right now overshadows everything else. Just a much more athletic and skilled game these days.
  23. This speaks volumes about the absolute dumpster fire that is the modern NBA. The worst American professional sports league and it isn't even close. Not sure how that speaks volumes about anything. Also, statistics (ratings and other metrics) show the exact opposite of what you're saying is true.
  24. Yeah, just felt like he wasn't comfortable with what he was seeing. Funny because he made the comment about the game being slow to him in preseason, but it definitely seemed like he had trouble processing quickly enough. I was especially concerned about him being seemingly unsure about basic concepts and coverages that he mastered at Ohio St. Like there were RPOs he didn't pull the trigger on and took sacks. And because they were RPOs (run blocking OL), it made the OL look much worse because of quick pressure, but the ball should be gone almost instantly. It's not like he's a dumb dude either. Historic wonderlic test, IIRC for whatever that's worth. But anyway, I do truly believe that a full camp will help him improve on this. The mechanics fix will help with the timing and get the ball released a split second quicker, but I think it's more mental than mechanical for him. Trusting what he sees. And that's why I'm pretty bullish on Getsy. Fields was one of the best deep ball passers in the league. He also was amazing throwing on the move (5 of 7 TD passes were on the move, only ones that weren't were touch pass to Grant vs. GB, quick hitter to Byrd also vs GB). And is crazy as it sounds, he just needs to get comfortable not looking to go deep or escape the pocket. Sure, he can be very successful doing what he does. But for him to meet his immense upside, he has to be able to make quick reads and get the ball to playmakers quickly. Him being a playmaker on his own is just icing on the cake. And I think that's what is meant by "doesn't need much help".
  25. He was going to be cut. Bears gave up the pick to not give him an open market. The Patriots run a pretty adaptable scheme, but I do think Harry is a better fit in the Shanahan scheme the Bears project to run. He's a good and willing blocker, which helps in outside zone. He's a big body who can shield defenders on a slant, which is good on RPOs. He doesn't separate or get open well, so you have to create separation for him at times. And the Shanahan O is big on making pass plays look like run (whether playaction or thru blocking scheme) so that will help Harry create some space. He and St. Brown are the only true X WR types the Bears have on the roster, and they are pretty similar low risk gambles. I think he'll make the team over guys like Moore, Sharpe, and Pettis; which makes him the 5th or 6th WR. If between he and St Brown you can get one of those guys to give you 20-30 catches (30-40 combined), then I'd call it a success.
×
×
  • Create New...