Jump to content
North Side Baseball

raw

Community Moderator
  • Posts

    5,716
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    7

 Content Type 

Profiles

Chicago Cubs Videos

Chicago Cubs Trade & Free Agent Rumors

2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospect Rankings

Chicago Cubs News, Rumors & Analysis

2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Chicago Cubs Fan Guides & Resources

2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Blogs

Events

Forums

Store

Gallery

Everything posted by raw

  1. Not to defend the Bears per se, but that used to be more common. The GM role also changed a lot in the past 30 years and became highly player personnel/scouting focused with the advent of the salary cap in the mid 90s. But I don't think the Bears were the last team to adopt a GM title (or reestablish, after firing Finks). A funny alternative history maybe exists where Michael doesn't eff up the McGinnis hiring and stays on as Pres until 2011, when George replaced him. Phillips never becomes CEO and they operate old-school with no GM even longer than they did. But Michael gets demoted and Phillips first big moves as CEO/Pres are the Soldier Field deal and hiring Angelo as GM. Angelo then tries recruiting Saban who turns him down mostly because he wanted GM duties. IIRC, Lovie was seen as like 3rd choice behind Saban and someone else. Fun sequence of events leading to a failed McGinnis hiring and then the best stretch of the Bears in the past 30 years. This made me look back because I don't remember that coaching search too well. Looks like the Bears interviewed Saban, Lovie, Jim Mora Jr, Romeo Crennel, Mike Nolan and Russ Grimm. Wow. Didn't remember those names. I probably wanted Lovie or Romeo, but I really don't know if I had a preference back then
  2. Yea. I'm not sure some of his defense of Fields i.e. the missed ESB route is totally legit or not, but the system simplicity stuff, and defining his reads more seems legit. I'm sure that comes with the downside of simplifying the defenses options too, but then that's where you just allow Fields to bail and create outside the pocket and the normal professions. And I loved when he laughed at the question about not having a good bail out target. Like yea, duh, that makes a difference. Yeah, he looked right at ESB. I think he saw the safety and thought he would make it there by the time he unleashed it. But yeah, I took the same things from it you did.
  3. IDK if anyone posted this in this or the other thread. But this actually makes me feel really good about Justin. Obviously, he's saying a lot of what we want to hear, but it makes a ton of sense.
  4. This doesn't surprise me at all. mentally I have been expecting to not see Lonzo until January at the earliest. If the surgery is 7 days from now and he's re-evaluated in 4-6 weeks that would put his re-evaluation in November. Even if he's cleared then, he'll probably need a few more weeks to get into basketball shape. Not seeing him til spring at best.
  5. thats been my impression as well. I get the impression that Fields is more inclined to be a passer first, where Hurts and/or Jackson are much more willing to channel their inner Jim Brown Maybe. But at the same time Fields isn't super inclined to be a pocket passer. I don't think that was true at Ohio State, but obviously he's still getting accustomed to the speed and bailing on the pocket. He still ends up running at times when a pass probably did exist. But then when he runs he isn't "looking to create" on the run. I guess it feels more reactive. I actually want him to run more at times. Granted, I can't see All-22, but whenever he holds onto the ball more than like 2.5 seconds, I think he should just take off. Even if the D has a spy on him, it's not a guarantee he's going to get caught by that guy, especially not before 3-4 yard gain. IMO, that's way better than him holding onto the ball, being more likely to be sacked or to force a throw that's not coming open.
  6. If Fields can't have success in this game, I'll be pretty worried. This is the same defense he's facing in practice. Same defensive scheme, probably similar level of talent which is young and talented on the backend.
  7. Add it to the list of Bears offensive futility. I swear that since I first remember watching the Bears regularly (1994) we've had about 10-12 offensive seasons that would be on most teams bottom 5 offensive seasons ever. Change the players, change the coaches, change the FO and we just cant figure out how to have any sort of success offensively, particularly passing offense. Dating back to 1994 they’ve had a defensive minded head coach in all but 6 seasons. The rest have all been defensive first and the bulk of those were guys in their final job, with minimal prior head coaching success. You can say they’ve changed coaches and still same results, but those changes have rarely shown a concerted effort to prioritize offense. It’s not some weird hex, it’s organizational but philosophy. Defense first. Maybe hire an offensive coach on occasion but if that fails go right back to defense first. We are back in a defense first situation and have to pray they magically find a qb or have a Ron Turner situation where the OC cobbles together a good season once or twice. Nope. It's a curse. Are we sure a goat never walked across the endzone in Soldier Field?
  8. BPA to me, has always been more a scouting/preparation thing. If you go in looking for a WR you can definitely justify it, but you're just opening yourself up to bad confirmation biases. So you kind of have to do the whole "7.34 v 7.32" rating thing with no positional/need bias and then when it actually comes down to it have more esoteric value based decision making. And it might actually be somewhat intuitive to directly "BPA" a WR and CB as an example, but is pretty impossible for a FS verse a G. Eta a guy I know online only and has pretty reputable claims to have done some contract work with nfl teams on systems design (mostly playbook stuff but has some exposure to draft systems) told me that the grading systems don't do nearly that level of granular grading. Probably more analogous to a 5 star rating system than a baseball type WAR metric. A little more complex, but not down to declaring 100th perctible variances across players. Yeah, BPA is in the eye of the beholder. One of the funny things was when the Cowboys draft board leaked this spring. They had a list of guys that would potentially fall to them, had a group with 1st round grades and then had a group after with 2nd round grades. They took Tyler Smith, who was their top 2nd round grade over their last 1st round grade on the board (I don't remember if it was a RB- Breece Hall or a safety). But that showed me, teams will claim BPA all day, but when it comes down to it, need plays a bigger role. Most teams would take a 4-star at a need position over a 5-star player at a deep position
  9. Hurts is bigger. He's a more willing runner, I wouldn't necessarily say more natural. Fields is a step faster, maybe more agile too. Seems like teams are playing for the moving pocket. Part of the reason the Bears are running the ball well is because when they show run action, the weakside DE is basically playing for the reverse pivot, taking a man out of the run play. They know the OL isn't good enough to keep the other 3 out of the pocket consistently if he does drop straight back. I feel like good teams with mobile QBs, don't do the naked bootleg stuff and leave their QB 1-on-1 with a DE. They actually commit an extra blocker to him so the QB has time and a lane to throw, even if on the move. Like I want to see Fields outside the pocket, but actually move the linemen, have a TE come across the formation to pick up that guy keeping contain. Hurts is bigger in what way? hes 6-1 223, Fields is 6-3 227 according to NFL.com https://www.nfl.com/players/jalen-hurts/ https://www.espn.com/nfl/player/_/id/4362887/justin-fields 223 on a 6'1" frame is bigger (aka thicker) than 227 on a 6'3" frame. Thicker frame means more willing/able to take a hit.
  10. Hurts is bigger. He's a more willing runner, I wouldn't necessarily say more natural. Fields is a step faster, maybe more agile too. Seems like teams are playing for the moving pocket. Part of the reason the Bears are running the ball well is because when they show run action, the weakside DE is basically playing for the reverse pivot, taking a man out of the run play. They know the OL isn't good enough to keep the other 3 out of the pocket consistently if he does drop straight back. I feel like good teams with mobile QBs, don't do the naked bootleg stuff and leave their QB 1-on-1 with a DE. They actually commit an extra blocker to him so the QB has time and a lane to throw, even if on the move. Like I want to see Fields outside the pocket, but actually move the linemen, have a TE come across the formation to pick up that guy keeping contain.
  11. What Philly has done with him is put him behind the best OL in the league. Also drafted and traded for WRs with 1st round picks. Bears are a long way from being able to emulate that. I wanted us to go that route so bad. I didn't even want to draft a QB until we started rebuilding the situation around the QB. Because I didn't want to end up exactly where we have ended up. The only good thing about losing to the Packers is it gets the rest of the fan base on board with my doom bonering 1. That's not necessarily the best route either, especially for a team like the Bears who have had seasons where everything is good enough, except the QB. They also kinda are building both at the same time (as WF said). They drafted 2 OL right after Fields in 2021. Both are currently starting. They also have a 3rd recent draft pick starting and a FA signing splitting time and eventually starting at C. Obviously, it's not good enough, especially combined with the lack of offensive weapons. But what's the alternative? Maybe you use a couple of the picks used to take/trade for Fields and got a lineman and a WR.....but the Bears were able to add young OL help, and a young WR with Nick Foles and Trevor Siemien throwing to him probably wouldn't instill a ton of confidence that we just needed a QB. 2. The doom bonering is pretty pointless. Nobody thinks this team is going to be any good. We've seen pretty good Bears teams get their asses beat in primetime in Lambeau. This was a game in May when the schedule came out that everyone marked as a loss. It wasn't any uglier than it usually is. I'm actually pretty stunned by the reaction. Well not really, but I think people were hoping that Fields would at least look good in a loss. But the bottom line was, this was going to be a loss. We all knew it well before kickoff.
  12. The off target % is bad there, but we're also dealing with such a small sample. Like the Mooney bomb was way off and that's 10% of his throws. Must have an impact. Over the course of last year, I believe advanced stats showed him to be a pretty accurate deep passer. The time to throw and target separation make sense based on what we've always known about Fields, even as a prospect. There's still a lot to work with and the O just has to meet him where he is and make marginal improvements in those araas over time. The Mooney throw, I'm sure counts as off-target, but it wasn't a bad throw. Mooney slowed down because he assumed the ball wasn't coming to him. That allowed the DB to get on top of him and make it look like a severe overthrow. If Mooney is going full speed the whole play, it may be a pass breakup, but I do think the throw is on target. But yeah, all these stats are grains of salt at this point.
  13. What Philly has done with him is put him behind the best OL in the league. Also drafted and traded for WRs with 1st round picks. Bears are a long way from being able to emulate that.
  14. Beyond a doubt, nearly any other QB would have pulled the trigger, overthinking, lack of confidence, playing scared, fearing a TO, is not going to work. He should know that if he doesn't, he 's as good as gone. I'm talking myself more and more into the belief that they just need to let him play freely and sink or swim. I think back to the Browns preseason game (yes I know it was a meaningless preseason game with starters sitting) but you could just see Fields start to get comfortable after a few throws and then suddenly he was electric and confidently throwing bombs all over the field. I think back to the Steelers game last year. In the first half he struggled with a gameplan that didn't involve many passes, in the 2nd half he hit a couple of perfect throws and then became unstoppable. I think if you give someone only a handful of attempts to make something happen, they're going to play more tentatively and scared because the margin for error is razor thin (like WrigleyField22 said). It certainly seems like the case with Fields. It was like that every game last year too. The offense would do nothing 1st quarter (or entire half in most cases) and then Fields would get into a rhythm and just play. Hell, he did that last week. But Pittsburgh, SF last year also come to mind.
  15. Exactly! I mean it's true. That talent is bad. But like I've said all offseason....do you spend a ton of money and force it? Miami is doing this with Tua. And granted, he had 6 TDs and 500 yards passing yesterday, but ultimately, he's probably not good enough for them to have spent all that money around him. And I'd imagine in a couple years, they're wasting tons of money on that supporting cast with inconsistent QB play and a few season that they have nothing to show for. NYG has done that for Daniel Jones, and again they are 2-0, but they probably aren't actually good and have no cap space to add a proven QB to that team next year. I love Fields as much as anyone on this board. My wife thinks I'd leave her for him if I ever actually met him (straight man crush). But at some point, he has to show some basic competencies of an NFL QB. He's still not throwing to open guys, when they do get open. He still isn't feeling the pass rush and moving in the pocket to avoid it. He's still holding onto the ball too long. And honestly, he hasn't really shown progress in that area. I know, new offense, new players everywhere, bad playcalling, whatever excuse you want to make, but they aren't going to sit around and spend huge money to add big-time talent around him if Fields isn't improving on those basic traits. Poles didn't need to cripple the franchise and he wouldn't have with a more meaningful and purposeful offseason. I agree Fields has work to do, but comon there is no way Poles offseason made any damn sense towards building any type of competent offense Again, I have said that there is a middle ground. He could have signed my favorite FA fit, Laken Tomlinson, and had one of the best guards in the league for the next 3-4 years. He could have drafted George Pickens over Kyler Gordon, who got his ass consistently handed to him last night in coverage and in the run game. But Poles' goal wasn't to build a competent offense. He wants to build a competitive team. That's both sides of the ball. He didn't completely ignore offense. He didn't do enough on offense, but based on last night, he didn't do enough on D either. For whatever reason, he felt he needed a clean slate from what Pace left him with and didn't have any picks or money to work with. It's completely understandable and not an unreasonable offseason. Sucks that Fields was caught in the middle of it, but that's what happens when you let a lame duck GM trade multiple picks for a QB and push money into the future.
  16. If the Bears drafted QB in the 1st every year, they'd still only have 1 more of them on the roster. They've traded like half of their 1st round picks in search of a QB or in pursuit of supporting cast around the guy they thought was their QB.
  17. This would be more convincing if it wasn't a copy-paste of the exact things I've been hearing about Bears QB busts since McNown. Exactly! I mean it's true. That talent is bad. But like I've said all offseason....do you spend a ton of money and force it? Miami is doing this with Tua. And granted, he had 6 TDs and 500 yards passing yesterday, but ultimately, he's probably not good enough for them to have spent all that money around him. And I'd imagine in a couple years, they're wasting tons of money on that supporting cast with inconsistent QB play and a few season that they have nothing to show for. NYG has done that for Daniel Jones, and again they are 2-0, but they probably aren't actually good and have no cap space to add a proven QB to that team next year. I love Fields as much as anyone on this board. My wife thinks I'd leave her for him if I ever actually met him (straight man crush). But at some point, he has to show some basic competencies of an NFL QB. He's still not throwing to open guys, when they do get open. He still isn't feeling the pass rush and moving in the pocket to avoid it. He's still holding onto the ball too long. And honestly, he hasn't really shown progress in that area. I know, new offense, new players everywhere, bad playcalling, whatever excuse you want to make, but they aren't going to sit around and spend huge money to add big-time talent around him if Fields isn't improving on those basic traits.
  18. He's looking down his primary receiver and holding the ball way too long. OK, I guess you are right. It's still a little too early. But what you posted is like deja vu for every other failed QB the Bears have had. It's too early, he doesn't have help, too many coaches, etc etc. I find it to be more likely at this point he will ultimately fail, for whatever reason(s) we want to point to. But since this season isn't going to be a good one anyway, I'm OK continuing to play him. He had 11 pass attempts all game. Failure is assured. He had 9 pass attempts while the game was still potentially competitive. 4 of them were screen passes. But to the original post, it's got nothing to do with the Packers. Especially Rodgers, you can't sit a dude for 3 years anymore (unless ironically, you actually have Rodgers, apparently). We've seen Mahomes and Herbert in recent years come out as MVP level players right away. Granted Mahomes sat a year. Lamar won MVP his 1st full year starting. Watson was pretty good, pretty quickly. Imperfect guys like Jalen Hurts had some decent success early on (albeit mostly with his legs). Even Josh Allen, who was more raw than Fields coming out, showed more flashes by this point. You have 3-4 years to figure out if these guys can play with the rookie deals and the decision on 5th year options for 1st round picks needing to be made. It's not unreasonable to expect to know leaning one way or another after 2 years. Granted, the 2nd year just started, but there's a pretty strong chance the Bears still don't know what they have in Fields by the end of this year because of the OL, weapons, 1st time play caller, whatever else. I don't think it's unreasonable for fans to have higher expectations than what they are seeing on the field. Even if it is, I don't think you should look to "fans" to have reasonable takes in the first place.
  19. To my non-expert, non-all-22 having naked eye, it appears as if he is struggling to get thru reads fast enough or moving on from them too quickly at times. It's hard for me to call ESB his 2nd read on that play. IMO, it was clearly set up for a blown coverage. The design of the play meant either a crosser or the overtop guy would come open (and actually, backside crosser was wide open as well). Maybe he was the 2nd read, but IMO it was pretty similar to a levels concept where it's a half or 1/3 field read and you take the underneath and you read both depending on where the LBs and safeties leverage is leaning. Finding the backside crosser, I would consider reading the defense. Of course, he made the right throw, so this isn't a knock. Just my 2 cents. Also the Pettis TD, I wouldn't call a "read" necessarily. It was a scramble drill play. Fields escaped the pocket and threw to the opposite of the field. Sure, he had 3 guys in his direct line of vision before flipping his hips to Pettis, but I've never questioned his ability to read defenses outside of the pocket on improvisation.
  20. Sounds like the team doesn't expect Bahktiari back this week, and Ian Rappaport doesn't expect either Bahk or Jenkins to play. Sounds like Runyan has a concussion so he may be out this week as well. Barnes and Walker at ILB may miss this week too. Not only are there no significant injuries from Week 1 on the Bears side that I know about, there may have been 0 injuries in general. I'm sure there's some nagging issues somewhere, but the only question seems to be if Lucas Patrick can snap and start at C over Sam Mustipher.
  21. Ugh. I hate this game. We already know how this ends. Packers are too good to go 0-2 in the division. And the more desperate team often wins in the NFL, especially when they have the superior talent. Aaron Rodgers owns us. Last year, GB got embarrassed Week 1 against the Saints, came back with a primetime home game against a division rival (Lions, MNF) the next week and dominated on their way to dominate per usual until January. But boy if they can pull this one off! Whole different outlook on the season. There were only 4 games on paper that look like clear losses for the Bears. While obviously nobody expects them to go 13-4, winning 2 of those 4 right out the gate would bode well for the potential of this rebuilding year. I honestly look at the weather differently from everyone else. It seems like the Bears were more affected by the weather than the Niners. Fields went from 2 gloves, to 1 glove, to no gloves on either hand, back to 2 gloves. The kicker was a headcase. The playcaller was coaching scared early in the game. I didn't really see the Niners really holding anything back, that's about what I expect to see from their offense, scheme-wise, but with results getting better against lesser defenses.
  22. I'm not "fine" with the FG decision, but if you're going to do that....do it with 1:00 left after a timeout. Still have 2 other TOs and maybe you get the ball back for 2 or 3 more plays. Of course, that's even still more reason to go for it on 4th since a failure is the same result that saves you 7 yards. I believe I read 64+ yard FGs have been made 2 of 47 attempts in NFL history. Those are terrible odds, especially not in Denver where I know at least 1 of those 2 kicks made it.
  23. With the time outs in hand, could have run at least, one more play if not, two, to give themselves better field position for the FG. I don’t think the issue was not having time to run plays. They clearly did with three TOs left. The issue came down to running down the clock and attempting a 64 yarder or making a 4th and 5 conversion. The HC thought they had a better shot with a long FG than a conversion. And that’s insane. Russell Wilson is considered one of the game's top QBs. Maybe not Rodgers, Brady, Mahomes elite, but I think most around the league consider him in that next tier of very good QBs. Yet, he has now had multiple coaches in multiple cities treat late game situations like they are working with Sam Darnold. IDK why Russ isn't making a bigger stink about this. Forced a trade from a situation where they didn't "let him cook" and still being treated like a 3rd class QB.
  24. They have Lamar Jackson, Jaylon Jones and Josh Blackwell all on the 53 who had 0 defensive snaps yesterday. I think they're all older than Graham as well.
  25. He missed just about all of training cam and preseason. I think the team liked him and was waiting for him to get 100% healthy But overall, I think when in doubt thus regime has picked to keep their guy over a Pace guy. Would have had to cut one of the guys they added for the 53 over Graham. Kept Pennel over Tonga. That Kingsley Jonathan dude over Sam Kamara, etc.
×
×
  • Create New...