A player making contact and remaining completely on top of base but very briefly not actually having contact and being called out is just not 'right'. An over slide is a completely different thing. This. Overslides, over-running the base, those are completely different than Javy's slide. Again, I don't think the people who determined how replay was going to be used really considered a slight disconnect from the base. I look at it as a loophole that managers are exploiting. Especially since in instances like Javy's slide, it's incredibly subtle. Agree. I think it's akin to the NFL reviews, in that you can't review one thing and come back and change the ruling on something else. I think in almost all cases, the opposing manager is reviewing if the tag got there before the baserunner touched the base. I feel like reviewing and coming back with "well, no he didn't tag him before he got to the base.....but he moved off the base slightly while the tag was still there" is pretty weak. Especially considering the tag could be a big part of the reason why the player ever so slightly came off the bag.