In the Playoffs, it isn't unusual for the top six to cancel each other out via match-ups and top D-men. So, if you don't have a strong bottom six and a solid goalie, it's hard to win. That's one of the reasons the Hawks won 2 Cups in 4 years; they roll four lines and have had very good goalie play. Pittsburgh's problem is they have a crappy bottom six and a terrible goalie. But, the other reality is that Pittsburgh has really dominated puck possession against Columbus, and puck possession drives wins. Malkin and Crosby look to be bit sheltered in zone starts, but that makes sense, given how much Pittsburgh drives possession: http://www.extraskater.com/team/pittsburgh-penguins/2013p#player-usage-chart. For comparison sake, look at the Blackhawks: http://www.extraskater.com/team/chicago-blackhawks/2013p, and the Blues http://www.extraskater.com/team/st-louis-blues/2013p.The Blues are much better team than Columbus right now (maybe not in the future though). And you can see how even this series was. Toews is a beast. Kane is ridiculous. Sharp and Hossa were completed negated by Handzus. Versteeg hasn't been awful, but wasn't good. Bollig is terrible. Oduya and Hjalmarsson drew the toughest assignments. Brookbank did a credible job of filling in for Seabrook. Nick Leddy is doing a great job (and I think you'll see him paired with Hjalmarsson next year; Oduya will likely be traded. And Roszival/Brookbank will work to break in another young d-man). The Hawks would have been better served going with Regin or Morin and sitting Bollig (and Handzus). The optimal lines are probably, at this point: 29-19-88 10-28-81 (I don't love Ben Smith here... but he's earned a shot, and with Pirri traded...) 20-16-65 11-12-23 Quenneville won't bring in Regin and Morin, though, since he needs the Handzus security blanket. But Handzus has been terrible this year, and a net drag. The two worst players on the ice against St. Louis were Handzus and Bollig. Switching up the lines allows Q to roll four lines, which was integral to success in the Cup years.