I think it's time to face facts, the meatheads were right. Starlin Castro is not a great baseball player. His play this year has been horrendous and has hurt the Cubs way more than it's helped and it's not a BABIP issue right now because his BABIP is sitting right where it needs to be. His walk rate is good for bottom 10 in the league and some dude named Jose Ramirez on the Indians who is hitting .190 has a higher offensive WAR than him. Ryan Theriot’s worst year with the Cubs (2007): .266/.326/.356 0.9 WAR Starlin Castro 2015: .265/.295/.337 -0.2 WAR