The 2010 team had some stars (Kane, Kessel) but the defensemen were VERY mid (Jack Johnson, etc.) and the goalies were Jonathan Quick and Ryan Miller.
2014 has largely the same team plus Oshie
But which player is better at "safe at first on a fielder's choice, takes second on a walk, takes third on a fly out, scores on a wild pitch" (i.e. the "Effective Homerun")?