Why? Have you ever done it? I think it is careless to dismiss it as a minor issue. The role of the catcher is very important to the whole process of pitching. They serve a larger purpose than just somebody to catch the ball. Rothschild does not call the pitches. Pre-game meetings and gameplans are important, but the P and C are pretty much on their own once the game begins. I never said to dismiss it, but it's way over emphasized. I think it's even more careless to insinuate that the P and C are on an island during the game, especially if the tandem isn't having success. How is it overemphasized? What is it less important than? What is it more important than? Of course the pitchers aren't on an island out there. That wasn't my point. The pitching coach's primary job is to prepare them, either mechanically or through scouting reports leading up to their start or appearance. Yes, there is communication involved during a game as well. But they do not call each and every pitch thrown, especially Rothschild. That is the job of the P and C, after the several informational meetings and scouting reports they have gone over with the pitching coach.