I don't know who you're talking to but I didn't once consider this as "helping" Pie by benching him. I'm suggesting benching him because he isn't hitting the baseball and Reed Johnson is. The manager's job is to put players in a position to succeed and give the Cubs the best chance to win every day - that would be Reed Johnson. The manager's job is to put the players on the field that would give the Cubs the best chance to win more games overall. Short term fixes to sacrifice long-term development is not the way to do that. Pie has no more he can learn in AAA. He adjusted to and mastered that league. He needs time to adjust to the major leagues, and the Cubs need time to evaluate him in their long-term plans. Neither is accomplished by benching Pie or sending him down. Pie has initially struggled for a few months at every stage of development. Once he adjusts, he's been a phenominal player, on all levels. The important thing right now is to not have a knee-jerk panic reaction and stunt his development even more just to get a below average offensive performance from CF for a month instead of a poor one. It could even be argued that his defensive value over Johnson makes up most of the offensive difference. The whole problem I have with it is what you just eluded to: you don't have this significantly better option to go to. You're getting only marginal, short term extra offensive production in Reed. It's really not that much more. And in return, you guarantee that Pie won't be productive in the 2nd half, so you're basically saying it's going to be Johnson all year unless a trade is made. You're locking yourself into the production of Johnson, essentially. Doesn't seem wise to me, but what do I know. IMO, Pie has looked overmatched in one game, that was last night against one of the better pitchers in the NL (Although he was having an off night he is still pretty good). Based on just watching him play, I think he is learning how to be patient with his at bats and to be more selective with what he swings at. His first few games he was swinging at everything, and then he started taking pitches that were down the middle in an attempt to adjust. Last night he was late on everything in his first couple of at bats, which means he was struggling to pick up the ball out of the pitchers hand. Then he started swing at pitches that were just out of the strike zone and high (pitches you have to swing a little bit sooner on if your going to hit, thus your judgement of where the ball is going to be will be a little off.). My point is he clearly has the talent to hit the baseball, we've see that throughout the minors, he just needs to learn to adjust to MLB pitching. I think it is clear that he is attempting to learn. Based on his talent levels, I think he will get it but he has to get playing time. It isn't like were gaining a whole lot with playing Johnson right now so I say take a little less production now and and have a chance at getting some great production in the future. On the topic of Soriano's injury, maybe time off will get him back on track but I love the fact that Murton will get some good playing time.