This is why people think Law and Goldstein are insufferable. A phrase like "extra guy at best" is just irritating and trolling. Up until this year, when Barney's WAR went through the roof, he was almost universally seen as a utility guy. So it's not that too far off base. Comparing Sczcur to Pierre is a good example of just irritating and trolling. A lot of fans get upset when these guy refer to a prospect or young player as a 4th outfielder, utility guy, or 4-5 starter, but those really aren't insults, assuming it's in reference to a fringy type of player and not a top prospect. However, it's hard to take the term "extra guy at best" as anything other than a knock on the player. If nothing else, Barney can be a great utility infielder with a decent bench bat for the next 5 years. Matt Tolbert's an extra guy at best.