What are you talking about? He's a .500 pitcher. He had an outstanding year last year, now he's making up for it with terrible play. you're right, looking at win-loss is THE BEST way to judge where a pitcher ranks on a range from best-average-worst scale. you got it solved. Maybe I should have said "average" pitcher. I'm talking about the quality of his pitching, which was way better than usual last year, and is now much worse. This is... no. Wrong.