got any numbers to support that ridiculous claim? didn't think so. honestly though, i would love to see you list all the instances where barrett's d cost the cubs a run. Well, using one formula for Runs Created, Barrett has generated 26.1 runs for us. I don't know what the "average catcher" would have generated, but taking Blanco's numbers and extrapolating them upward to equal Barrett's playing time, you come up with 11.5 RC. Doing the same with Koyie Hill you get 2.4 RC. On the other side of the coin, I can think of 3 or 4 instances where Barrett's defense or bone headed base running contributed to a CUBS loss. Some will undoubtedly argue that there are more. I can't imagine that there are enough runs given up by Barrett to negate the extra offense he brings, in spite of his current slump. Thank-you, Fred. That sums it up. Barrett may have cost the Cubs a run here or there, but I doubt he's cost anywhere near the 15 run difference between him and Blanco. I agree that Barrett probably still outdoes Blanco, but I think Blanco's extrapolated numbers skew the numbers a little bit against him. He has only had 36 AB's, and I don't think it's reasonable that he'd stay at a .481 OPS if he got more AB's and a better sample size. He's had 8 full time seasons, and his worst one was a .524, with his second worst at .602. So he'd still be horrible at the plate, but he would have to make up a few less runs on Barrett if he was at .602 rather than .481, and I don't think .602 is optimistic at all (his last 3 years have been .628, .678, and .723).