Neifi. You go back and look, and the defensive metrics really did like him and his WAR says he may not have been as bad as we thought. Nah, I don't need to ruin my outlook of him. I'm comfortable with it. I figured Neifi would be a better choice though. Yeah, picking Neifi is going to be based on his defense; his reputation for awfulness then and now was justifiably based out of his wretched offense, and there's no revisionist history going on there. It still sucks when you look back. That and Dusty batting him at the top of the order all the damn time.