You're picking and choosing at this point. And the 22.5 mil last year was ranked? Where his DYAR was 16th, DVOA was 21st, and his QBR was 25th among the qualified QBs? That's right, it was the largest cap hit in the League. That's kinda my point. Where he ranks contract-wise doesn't matter, because they structured the contract to give him more money in the first year simply for cap flexibility later in the contract. It looks ridiculous now because he clearly had a bad year. But at the time, it made a lot of sense. The other point is that there's some mediocre QB's that are making way too much money (Smith/Bradford) because there's such a dearth of QB talent out there. Yep, Bears gave Cutler too much money. Emery lost his job over it. That doesn't change the fact that Cutler is the best the Bears can do as far as QB talent right now, and the best move is to make the best we can of it. The problem is you're worrying about him being "worth the contract". Put it out of your head. He's not going to be "worth the contract". Like you said, it's almost impossible for him to be so. There was almost no way for Alfonso Soriano to justify his contract, and there's little chance that Derrick Rose ever justifies his contract. That doesn't mean that those players can't, or in Soriano's case didn't, perform very solidly and be a highly productive member of their teams.