Really? I mean...I like Murton a lot too, but I think the chances of him being as good as Cabrera are low enough that the trade would definitely be do-able. Stats so far for this season... Cabrera AVG .346 | HR 3 | RBI 11 | OBP .443 | SLG .635 Murton AVG .280 | HR 2 | RBI 9 | OBP .345 | SLG .480 You try to keep your BEST players. I'd rather have Murton AND Cabrera not Cabrera AND Jones. That kind of negates the benifit of adding Cabrera doesn't it? Based on WHO you replace. Just like Replacing Cedeno with Tejada now wouldn't help us much, because Ronny is performing really well!! Well sure, ideally you'd love to give up nothing and get something, but chances are the Marlins are going to want actual talent back for Miguel Cabrera. I'm simply saying that if Murton is a "must" in order to get Cabrera, I'd be ok with that (of course the rest of the package would have an impact on that as well.)