It is not arbitrary. The statement made was the he starts fast and his numbers fade over the last four months of the season. That has been the pattern - I know you favour comparing apples to oranges but doesn't make any sense. That's why you compare the same period in each year. I am picking the same months from each year to compare - you are picking different months from each year - you are being far more arbitraty than I. LOL Why are you only looking at May. What happened to April??? April is part of April and May. Because that weakens the argument you just leave it out?? That assertation was those months the last two years have been better than the last four. Sure there have been periods during those months where has hit well but if you but they are different each year. Where to this point April and May, through 3 years, have been similar. The suggestion that splitting the season in two at the same point every year is too arbitrary but then supporting your arguments by pulling different smaller periods each year is laughable. What in God's name are you talking about? I'm pointing out how you're arbitrarily splitting the season up into two very different periods just to spin it to fit your point. I was saying you should use different arbitrary comparisons; I was pointing just some of the combinations you could do that would presumably have equal weight to the arbitrary combination and generalization you're flogging to make your point. I'm not "ignoring" any month. He was excellent in April; he was also excellent in July and August. You keep pushing April/May as some kind of period of great play he never duplicated, but he essentially did for another two month period later in the season. So why do you examine the first two month period on its own, but the second two month stretch of good play can only be looked at when lumped in with the two sub par months? See what I'm getting at? Your analysis of his year is totally arbitrary. You're doing everything you can to downplay his later good play, nevermind it's a two month stretch that's actually better than April and May, so that you can sum it up so it sounds like he's a got a 2-year pattern going where he slides after the first two months.