There's no justification in sending Murton down. Let me run through these arguments and disprove them: -He has a poor SLG% and we need a guy like Carlos Lee. I agree, we need a better SLG% out of LF, but we're not sending him down and bringing up Lee, nor are we trading for him, so this argument is crap. If you want to sign Lee this winter, ok, but demoting Murton isn't a precondition of that. -He needs to work on hitting with Von Joshua Yeah, Joshua is a better coach than the ML guys, but why, then would you keep the ML guys? Wouldn't every hitter benefit from a better hitting coach? Why just send Matt down? Wh not call Joshua up, so to speak? -He's struggled in June and has 5 RBI since May 1st. Yes, he has. So have half the team. Hit run production suffers because our offense sucks as a whole. Aramis has around 40 RBI, which for him is really, really low. Our whole offense is bad; why punish one kid for it? -He's not the answer in LF. On a competently constructed team, he can be an asset. You can allow him to grow into his role. However, this is the Cubs, and they stupidly constructed a team where Murton was counted on to be a run producer right away. Them when he hits a skid thanks to bad coaching and pressure from a stupid manager to be more aggressive, you send him down? Given that we're nowhere close to contending, I see no point in demoting him to learn facing AAA pitching. The best thing the Cubs could do is recognize that their hitting coaches are terrible, fire them, promote Joshua, and allow Murton to grow as a player and play through his struggles. Platooning him with Bynum does nothing ni the short term and damages our options in the long term.