CF, 2B/Util, 2B ---- CF, SS/Util, RF Not a very fair comparison. Expound.. Those 3 guys had about 1500 or so at-bats in the 1,2 & 5 spots. Simply plugging hypothetical players in spots in the lineup and saying they're better for the team is unfair. Sure, Hairston is a better #2 option than Neifi, but can Jerry play SS? Soriano is a better #5 hitter than Burny, but can or will he play RF? If Sori is at 2B, where's Hairston?