Well I suppose I'm talking to the wrong fans - most of my Cub fan friends believe Sandberg was great defensively. Or they are telling me that just to boast. . whatever. I remember Willie McGee, he is my fav player of all time in St. Louis. Unfortunately, I was too young to really evaluate him like I have been able to with Edmonds. I too wonder how the two would be remembered if they played in similar circumstances (not just TV and ESPN, but the style of play - defense and speed were the norm in St. Louis then, McGee may not have stood out like Edmonds does in a home run era) That said, Edmonds isn't the fastest or quickest in the OF - and I think his anticipation allows him to get to balls that he wouldn't get to, ala Sandberg. Since I've had DirectTV and St. Louis local channels (starting in 2002) I've probably watched 80-85% of Cards games. Followed them religiously before but couldn't watch as many. It's my personal belief that Edmonds takes way too much heat for diving. The fact is that he makes plays that most don't. Maybe he doesn't need to dive here and there, occasionally. But the catch in KC, the catches in Cincinnati, the one against Houston in 2004 - those plays aren't being made around the league with the regularity that Edmonds made them, except for Torii Hunter, maybe Andruw Jones. Others have said he dives for balls others get to easily. I'm not sure I agree with that 100% but if that's the case, it's quite often due to the fact that Edmonds is playing shallow, taking away short CF. It is my opinion that Edmonds is damned either way. Most people hate him because they think he showboats, and that affects the way they view him. I'd love to see anybody point me to a clip where Edmonds pauses and watches a homer. Even when Z hit him, Edmonds homered the next time and put his head down. Anyway - enough of this rant. Cub fans aren't alone - the Astros fan I work with thinks he showboats at the plate. . . if you wanna gripe about staring down dingers, the conversation and hate should begin and end with Albert.