I'd take Ching and Gomez over Buddle and Adu. If Charlie can't go, take Buddle. I don't value the tactical flexibility Adu brings like you because a) I don't think he'll actually be capable of pulling anything genius off due to rust, lack of confidence and/or just being poor, b) he doesn't deserve to go and his ego doesn't need the validation, c) Bradley has never shown the ability to get the most out of Freddy and d) Gomez and Ching's value on set pieces is far, far more likely to be what gets us scoring against a potential bunker than Adu's creativity. Buddle is a red card liability, he's on a rich vein of finishing form right now, but we have a huge sample size over his lengthy MLS career to look at and see he is a poor finisher whereas with Gomez we can at least point to injury and being played in the midfield as the reason he never lived up to his goal scoring potential. Also, Gomez and Ching don't lose possession or blow chances like Buddle. Even with his brace Saturday, I counted 6 times in the first half where he made a bad decision or bad link up pass that resulted in a turnover or GK. With the Galaxy, he is the guy. He is the only center forward and with Landon playing wide, the only person in position to score who can actually do it. It allows him to be selfish and beat up bad defenders like Nat Borchers. With the MNT, he needs to be a complimentary forward to Jozy, Charlie or Deuce. I have no reason to believe he's capable of that tactically or physically. He's a truly [expletive] passer. Can't hold the ball up and link with other forwards.