I'm not so sure. 2007- Dunn: 267/387/560 134 OPS+ Howard: 259/331/552 135 OPS+ Both are 27, so age isn't a factor. Career Dunn: 249/381/520 129 OPS+ Howard: 288/393/599 148 OPS+ Howard is a bit better over the career, but Dunn has played in more than double the games Howard has. Neither are great defensively. Both would be best served as a DH. I think the two are quite comparable and there's little to substantiate that Howard is that much if any better than Dunn. They're about even in VORP this year, but Howard has been banged up. Last year Howard had an 81.5 VORP, while Dunn's was 23.5. Howard's career EqA is .324, compared to .302 for Dunn. Howard's WARP3 was 9.5 last year and is 9.2 this year; Dunn's numbers were 5.0 and 6.3. Given that Howard's first full season was 2006 and he put up numbers that were far, far better than Adam Dunn in any season, I'd say it's pretty clear that he's the better player.