My animosity is toward Hendry for once again overpaying for underperformance. Exactly. This is an issue that probably is more relevant to the Cubs' poor planning and lack of vision. Maddux's option for 400 innings wasn't ever really in question. Being the icon that he is, Maddux was never going to be sat down, no matter how much he struggled. In addition, his injury history (or lack thereof) and his yearly accumulated innings numbers left little doubt that Maddux's option would vest. Maddux's $9M in 2006 can't be justified as money the Cubs expect him to earn. Even if you average out his salary for 3 years, $8M is too much to have expected to spend on him. The Cubs are paying for past performance and will likely suffer for it. Based on last year's and this year's money and games started and won
Total Sal GS W $/GS $/W
Maddux $15mill 62 27 $241,935 $555,555
Wood $17.5mill 32 11 $546,875 $1,590,909
Prior $6.7mill 44 16 $152,272 $418,750
Z $4.21mill 59 28 $71,355 $150,357