Yes, and I watch every game as well. I think he's been fine and better than last season's Khabi (particularly playoff Khabi) -- thus an apt demonstration of the subjective nature of the eye. Without an objective standard measuring scoring chance quality, there's no way to say to resolve a disagreement like this. Hockey statistics are far, far behind baseball's in measuring the game (though they are making strides). Your opinion has as much weight as mine when it comes to watching a game and drawing conclusions. The reason that I bring up playoff Khabi is because people (not you) were just talking about how the Hawks won't make it out of the first or second round because of the goaltending situation. Khabi was fine, but not great last season in the playoffs. The Hawks did just fine. I don't really care that you defended Huet last year -- though you may recall that I did as well -- my point is that he has been a very good goalie this year. Like any other goalie, he gives up terrible, soft goals sometimes. Sometimes he makes great saves, and contrary to what you seem to think, he's made quite a few very, very good saves. Generally, the Hawks defense tends to smother an opponent and leaves them with fewer shots on goal -- they give up the least in the league. But the chances that they do give up, based on the aggressive stretch and puck possession game, tend to lead to a lot of 2 on 1's and 3 on 2's. Huet's two problems as a goalie are that he doesn't move laterally all that well, and he is inconsistent with his rebound control (though much better than Niemi). When passes get through on an odd man rush, they tend to end up in the back of the net. With respect to him losing sight of the puck, that's a direct consequence of the Hawks aggressively trying to block shots. Complaining constantly about the goaltending situation, particularly after a loss in which the goalie played well and the defense didn't is meatball-ish. Huet is playing well right now, after a stretch of not playing well. Which followed an extended streak of excellent play. Which followed a really crappy stretch in October. Huet's definitely deserved criticism at points during the season, but not right now.