It wouldn't surprise me either way, to be honest. They have a need for him, but 4 players locked up to huge deals through 2016-2017 is a lot, even for the Yankees. Their major future commitments: ARod: through 2017, age 37 in 2012 - 29/28/25/21/20/20 CC: through 2016 w/2017 vesting option, age 32 in 2012 - 23/23/23/23/25/25 Teix: through 2016, age 32 in 2012 - 22.5/22.5/22.5/22.5/22.5 Wilson (hypothetical, just for the sake of it, assume 5/85 deal): through 2016, age 32 in 2012 - 12/13/15/20/25 That would be $90.5 million committed in 2016 to 4 players - one age 41 and three age 36. I know it's the Yankees, but that's a lot of cash invested in old players. It's the Yankees, they would still have $112 million (more assuming inflation) to spend on the rest of the team. Six of the playoff teams from this year were constructed for less money.