Your last paragraph is it. Obviously, the prospects are going to get every chance to hold down jobs. But the fact is, Baez has had a good 3 days. Alcantara has had an OK month. Bryant and Soler aren't guaranteed to just carry over their minor league numbers. One of these guys is probably going to fail at some point. Can't go into a season trying to compete with just 7 guys you think are going to be reliable (not counting Catcher). I think you keep both and best case have a loaded bench. I'm sure they can use the "keep everyone fresh" and "not overwhelming the kids" excuses to sit a guy every now and then. Soler may still need a day off a week, since he's never played anything close to 162 games in a season. So, you throw Coghlan or Ruggiano in there. I don't see why Valbuena couldn't play some LF, 2B, and 3B giving time off to Bryant, Soler, and Baez. Yeah, ideally you would trade away an .880 OPS guy for help elsewhere, if you are only going to be able to get him around 200 AB's. Since his value in a trade could net you something nice, and we have Ruggiano and Sweeney as back-up options, it makes sense. But, like you said, we also have Soler with an injury history, and everyone is really young and inexperienced. It's probably best to have as many back-up options as possible, in case things go awry with the prospects. Bryant is the main piece of the puzzle for the rest of the line-up, though. If he stays at third, then Coghlan probably gets a lot of playing time in LF next year. Or Rusney -- fingers crossed. And Valbuena becomes a super utility guy. If Bryant is in LF or RF, then Valbuena plays every day at third, and maybe we do move Coghlan.