Jump to content
North Side Baseball

Derwood

Old-Timey Member
  • Posts

    89,919
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    99

 Content Type 

Profiles

Chicago Cubs Videos

Chicago Cubs Trade & Free Agent Rumors

2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospect Rankings

Chicago Cubs News, Rumors & Analysis

2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Chicago Cubs Fan Guides & Resources

2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Blogs

Events

Forums

Store

Gallery

Everything posted by Derwood

  1. I agree. It helps that ESPN is treating his every at bat like that of Barry Bonds. Plus other media sources are really putting some stock in AJ. I just find it hard to believe that Albert or Lee do not win it. Jones has had far more RBI opportunities and his supporting cast is far better than that of the Albert's. Moreover, I do not see how you can give the MVP to a hitter that is batting around .275 when you have two guys batting .340ish with better OBP and Slg %. Here are the number is comparison with the NL leaders: OBP 1. Albert .434 4. Lee .423 31. Jones .358 Slg% 1. Lee .674 2. Albert .633 3. Jones .601 BA 1. Lee .343 2. Pujols .338 40. Jones .275 I could see how voters could reward D. Lee for a great season or Albert for being so consistant on the best team in MLB (record wise). Yet, to give it to Jones is just absurd. What are the numbers for runs, RBI and runs created?
  2. If you switched Perez and Murton, you might have something
  3. Venice is largely a theme park. I've seen historical areas of German cities and I like how they were restored, but I wasn't familiar with them before the bombing in the 40's. As for New Orleans, maybe I'm cynical, but in America in the year 2005 I can't see any rebuilding project not having a cheezy commercial flavor. I've been to NO before the flood and even then I thought it was already overly commercial and touristy. Ever think that you were probably in the commercial and touristy areas of the city? Still, while I think they will definitely have to do something to entice people back to the area, I doubt that they are going to build a large scale version of Celebration, FL
  4. Finally, a game I can watch. The other 3 I was either working or blacked out by the demon spawn at FOX
  5. Why do you think certain pitchers get more run support than others on the same team? As long as my team scores more than the other team, I'm happy... Yeah, it's too bad now that Clemens is old he sucks at getting his team to score lots of runs. that's what your argument boils down to, and it's just absurd. I can't believe anyone would want to argue your side of things edit: I can't believe anyone other than joe morgan would want to argue your side of things I think you're looking at my argument the wrong way. Joe Morgan thinks that the pitcher with the most wins should be the Cy Young winner because he is the best pitcher. I think the Cy Young should go to the pitcher who has done everything in his power to win games, meaning era, whip, baa, etc. because that is the individual who has literally "pitched" the best. (Clemens has pitched the best this season). That being said, a pitcher who cannot win is not as valuable to his team in a particular contained season than one who can, regardless of other stats. I guess I don't have any other way of phrasing this... I've said it several times. Perhaps "valuable" isnt the correct word to be using, because people tend to associate value with achievement. Trust me, happening to get more run support than a teammate doesn't make your personal accomplishments any greater, but for certain players, it does occur. It's almost certainly luck, but it happens, and the bottom line is, the team wins more often when the guys with the greatest differential between runs scored and runs allowed are pitching. If I had to take my pick for one season, I would take a mediocre pitcher who was incredibly lucky over an excellent pitcher who was unlucky if 10 more wins for my team was the bottom line. That being said... when trying to build a team, do you look for a pitcher like, say, Russ Ortiz, to anchor your rotation because he won 20+ with a higher era? No. You have no idea how the offense will support him the next year. Maybe he had a lucky season. Maybe the team felt more confident when he was pitching.. you just don't know and for that reason you need to look for guys who allow the least runs per game. I'm just trying to say that when the season is said and done, and you're looking back on it (as we are with Maddux), can you honestly say (as a team) you were better off with a pitcher who has a low era and less wins, or one with a higher era and almost double the wins? So please don't lump Joe and I together. Other than a taste for Ron of Japan and fine silk suits, we don't have much in common. With that note, I think I'm going to stop trying to get this point across. I don't know if it is a lack of eloquence or what, but I continue to get misinterpreted (e.g. 'Yeah, like way to credit a picher for getting run support') and it's not worth it for me to continue to try rewording my original post. I guess we're going to have to agree to disagree on this one. :D Can I assume, then, that given a vote, you would choose Carpenter to win the CY over Clemens because Clemens just "can't win" this year?
  6. If the MVP was given out by sabermetricians, all this talk of VORP and Win Shares and such would be fine. But it's not. It's given by people who likely either cast their ballot at the 11th hour in a rush, or give people awards based on the "sexy" numbers like HR and batting average. I think Andruw Jones wins it simply because of his HR numbers and his hot finish to the season. I'm not saying he should, but that he will.
  7. Glad to see an offensive outburst from Penn State, especially the three lightning fast freshmen. Too bad the defense tired out/gave up/stopped playing at the end. Cincy scored 2 TD's in the final 39 seconds to make it 42-24, when it was really a 42-10 domination by the Nittany Lions.
  8. I think Dusty brokered a deal with Hennessey before the game to get his boy back in the lineup. "Go for the hand dude, go for the hand."
  9. FOX doesn't make the rules. Complain to MLB. With its myriad of Internet and mobile ventures, MLB is at the cutting edge of sports broadcasting. Why they conduct Saturday regional telecasts like it's 1972 is a mystery to me. Thankfully there are ways around the regs. I know, but FOX did broker the deal, as you said, like it's 1972. We have sattelite TV for crissake, people don't need the "Game of the Week" in order to follow their favorite teams (and with FOX, your favorite team better be the BoSox, Yanks, Cards, Cubs, Braves, Dodgers or Giants)
  10. You're going to have to update those of us who have been thwarted by FOX's evil stranglehold on Saturday day game baseball. Sorry. It's on Comcast here. bloop single Winn blooper caught by Hairston double off RF wall by Snow scores Winn (edited) Alou walks 1-0 Giants That's it for now. Link to sportsline box: http://www.sportsline.com/mlb/gamecenter/live/MLB_20050910_CHC@SF Thanks. I have the espn.com gamecast going now Was that a DP to end the inning?
  11. You're going to have to update those of us who have been thwarted by FOX's evil stranglehold on Saturday day game baseball.
  12. I'm not shocked by anything Dusty does anymore
  13. Either he'll get shelled for 5 runs in 2 1/3, or he'll throw 147 pitches in an 11-0 blow out.
  14. I think it's pretty clear he doesn't. And hey, look! He's playing a "young" guy! Scott McClain!
  15. Yep, I missed it. That was a short game for me :oops: :( :cry:
  16. Same reason he hits his 4th highest RBI man (Barrett) in the #8 position most of the season. Because he's STUPID.
  17. "I'll drink up all the Hennesy you got on your shelf, So just let me introduce myself, My name is Humpty, pronounced with an "umpty", Hey ladies, oh how I like to funk thee, And all the rappers in the Top 10, please allow me to bump thee." /digital underground
  18. Well there was no percentage that could account for LaTroy
  19. what if pitcher just wins for 15 straight years?is it still circumstancial? and what if pitcher misses 20 starts in a 2 year period with those stats? No, it's not circumstancial that Maddux won 15+ for all those years. In fact, he was arguably the best pitcher in baseball for 10-12 of those years. But you can't begin to tell me that this year's version of Maddux even resembles those of the 4 Cy Young Awards.
  20. Or Cleveland, of course.
  21. I'm going with pitcher B, and it isn't even close. Right, of course it isn't. My point being that many people here are arguing for Maddux because he falls under the PITCHER A type (those aren't Maddux's numbers, obviously, but he isn't winning because he dominates)
  22. Had the Cubs not been swept by the Mets and lost 2 of 3 to the Phillies during that 8 game skid, I might agree.
  23. Sorry to belabor this "Wins vs. Stats" debate, but I pose this question: Who is the better pitcher: PITCHER A: 20-13, 4.85 ERA, 1.40 WHIP, .300 OBA, received 6.2 runs per game of support. or PITCHER B: 11-7, 3.25 ERA, 1.15 WHIP, .234 OBA, received 3.9 runs per game of support. Pitcher A "just wins", but those wins are more circumstancial than earned, while Pitcher B has been a better performer, but hasn't found the right days to pitch.
×
×
  • Create New...