If you assume that 99% of all message board posters on the internet have little to no baseball ability...which I guess is a safe bet. Straight as an arrow 100 mph fastballs, more than a handful of guys here could make contact. 99% is a bit high. The majority, however, would struggle to make contact. Edit: I didn't notice his statement about being told the exact location of the pitch being thrown. If you knew the speed and location, that obviously increases your chances of success by quite a bit. Sure, they would make contact. None of them would get a hit though. No way. Pop ups and groundouts.