Call me crazy (and you will), but I think you've got to count on Prior as the #2 starter. The recovery period is over. Either he can pitch or he can't. If his arm is hurty, send him down or DFA. If not, run him out for 200 innings. If he's lost his control, demote or DFA. None of this #5 starter garbage. He's shown he's an Ace, but if his arm is shot you can't just make him a #5. And for some more blasphemy, is Wood ever going to start again? Has he lost interest in the role? Are the doctors saying his arm will fall off if he ever goes 9 innings? Again, if his arm is good he should pitch like he used to, if it's shot...to the scrap-heap! He's never going to embrace the role of middle relief, but does he want to make himself a closer? (serious question) That would be fine too, but if it's a lingering injury concern I'd start over with a fresh arm. To summarize: These guys aren't marginal pitchers. If they're healthy but no longer great then they're flamed out so just cut your losses.