Yeah, the stupid side of the debate (Flacco has as many Super Bowl rings as Rodgers and Peyton so he must be as good!!) is really annoying. love it or hate it, in today's NFL, super bowls are won by very good to great quarterbacks. So, I presume by "today's NFL" you mean after Trent Dilfer and Brad Johnson won Super Bowls? It's a chicken and the egg issue. Do great QB's lead teams to Super Bowls or does winning a Super Bowl cause us to elevate a QB to "great" status?