I hope its us but I feel like its SF I think I'd rather have Anderson for that tier of starter, but I'm not really sure. I think I would agree, but it's 2:30a and I forgot he was a thing. Anderson's issues have been more injury related than anything. To me, Masterson is probably more mechanical and will probably cost a bit more than Anderson or he just actually sucks. They're both a lottery ticket though so I think I would trust the decision of the FO and who they think Bosio would be most likely to fix. I'm in the Anderson lottery ticket camp. He's a legit TOR pitcher when healthy (2.91 ERA, 2.99 FIP, 3.55 xFIP pitching in Colorado last year) . His injury issues last year weren't arm/shoulder related (not that a back injury isn't worrying). The Cubs are the type of franchise who can take a gamble on him. They're in Win Now mode, and if it doesn't work out they have the salary padding to eat a short term bad contract and a small army of end of rotation candidates to eat up his missed innings. I almost prefer Anderson to Shields, given the contracts they're likely to get.