In all honesty there really isnt a fair comparison IMO. OOTP9 is deeper, richer, more imersive baseball experience. It is a Text Sim. If you want Madden style graphics and that is all that is important to you then stay away from OOTP. If you think you could do a better job running the Cubs than MacPhail or Hendry have done the last decade then this is the sim for you. From the Arizona league to Chicago you can have control over the full minor league system, or if you want to you can simulate the way baseball was from 1901. All you have to do is import that year and start your league. Honestly it is about that easy too. OOTP is all about options and the community has talented modders to fill in the cracks for what they cant give you because of legal reasons. The game ships with opening day rosters from this year, but not with the team logos. Easy enough to fix. Download the ICEY mod and now your players pictures will have the correct jersey and cap logos along with the correct logos on team pages all the way down your system to rookie ball. I have been playing since OOTP3. Every year it has made strides improving, and becoming more imersive. Yes the AI isnt as great as a human opponent but for an AI, I have seen lots worse out there. Go to the boards and ask any questions you have. There is a very helpful, dedicated, and knowlegeable set of fans over there. http://www.ootpdevelopments.com/board/ootp-9-general-discussions/