I thought I made it clear, that if its somebody thats a perienniel (sp?) All-Star, their judgement is alot better. Swinging at the first pitch may be okay. But in certain situations, you do NOT swing at the first pitch. Situations you don't want to do that in 1) bases loaded, less then 2 outs. 2) RISP, batters ahead of you have walked 3) Sac fly situation, looking for a ball to drive. Sometimes a gamble will pay off, but I'd assume as a player you want to play things safe when your team needs wins, and is in the heat of a playoff chase. Its all about situations. You adapt to the situation. Corey's problem, is he's not adapting. He goes to the plate every day with the same mentality and philosophy. As I type this, Brenly's talking about selecting pitches. Guys like Pujols, Tejada, Vlad, Arod. These guys are VERY selective, and I can't recall the last time I saw them hack at the first pitch once, let alone twice in a game.