I'll concede most of those except the pitching distance. Young had only been pitching 3 years when it changed from 50 feet to 601/2. Probably, but I think the same could be said for the hitting greats of their time. You bring Ty Cobb, Tris Speaker, or Honus Wagner up to today's ballparks and they'd destroy. First off, the usually only played with one ball the entire game which pitchers were ALLOWED to scuff up, spit on, grind in dirt, etc. So by the later innings it is said that the pitch looked like a knuckleball but at the speed of a fastball. Second, their bodies weren't taken care off like the players of today. They had to be tough or they wouldn't play. Hell, Cobb had his tonsils removed with anesthetic minutes before a game against the White Sox in like 1915 and still had like 3 hits. I think in the end it's all relative. Great talents are great talents regardless of the era. People like inflated averages like Cobb's or Hornsby's and they'd naturally want to say "well, I guess everyone had averages like that", which isn't true. League BA's are the same back then as they are now. But indeed, respect or not, Cy Young's records are just absurd and his era should be taken into consideration, but I don't think an asterisk is fair.