I'd have to agree. However, I think Griffey would have toppled 800 if it wasn't for his injuries :\ Griffey joins Mantle as the greatest "should have been" players ever. Hmm...Jimmy Foxx has to be considered, doesn't he? Jimmie, and yes he should be considered. Problem is, he was a first baseman, and he just wasn't as good as Gehrig (.346 EqA versus .329 EqA). When I put Eddie Collins on the team as the utility IF, i was thinking more about guys who would be able to fill the utility role... but Foxx could arguably be ahead of Collins. Foxx was a better hitter, but Collins provided a lot more offense over the average 2B, and he was also good for a longer period of time than Foxx.