Chicago Cubs 2026 Position Analysis: Catcher

The catching position is as involved as any in baseball, seeing that whoever is behind the plate factors into every single pitch. The Chicago Cubs’ catching position has everything from a grizzled veteran who is coming off of a career year to up-and-coming talents with varying levels of upside. Here is a full breakdown of the North Siders' backstop situation heading into the 2026 season.

Cubs Catchers At A Glance 

Starter: Carson Kelly

Backup: Miguel Amaya

Depth: Moises Ballesteros

Prospects: Christian Bethancourt, Casey Opitz, Ariel Armas

Cubs starting catcher fWAR last year: 11th out of 30

Cubs fWAR ranking projection this year: 16th out of 30

The Good

Regardless of what the Cubs were expecting to get out of Carson Kelly in his first season with the team, he exceeded those standards. Chicago’s veteran backstop posted career marks in batting average (.249), hits (92), RBI (50) and runs scored (48), among other statistics. Arguably the most awe-inspiring figure was this: Kelly logged just 4.1 WAR over the first nine years of his career. In 2025 alone, he logged 3.6. 

One of the reasons Kelly had a breakout season at the plate was his plate discipline. His strikeout rate (19.0) and walk percentage (10.7) both beat the league-average marks, and it allowed him to capitalize in a crucial way: the pull-side air raid. 

While the majority of Kelly’s balls in play were to left field, he found a way to get out in front of pitches at a remarkable rate this year. The 31-year-old catcher capitalized on a career-high in Pull AIR%. 

Kelly wasn’t the only player who put up a career year, though. Miguel Amaya hit a personal-best .281 with a .500 slugging percentage that eclipsed his previous career-high of .359. Furthermore, after hitting just eight home runs across 117 contests the year prior, Amaya swatted four long balls in just 28 games. Call it hunger for more playing time if you want, but the 6-foot-1, 230 pound catcher found his power stroke in the 2025 season. 

Moises Ballesteros, while very young, flexed his hitting abilities as the team’s top prospect in his debut last year. The 22-year-old Venezuelan has always been a standout talent for his elite bat-to-ball skills, and the 60-grade hit tool on his scouting report reinforces that narrative. Very possibly the Cubs catcher of the future if his defense can hold up, Ballesteros registered a .298 batting average with an .868 OPS. He throttled a pair of home runs and served as a shot in the arm for an at-times anemic Cubs offense in the second half.

The Bad

It’s a rare sighting to see a player on the other end of 30 years old put up career numbers. Even if Kelly were to replicate his incredible 2025 season, he has a year left on his contract before a mutual option kicks in. 

That places a plethora of pressure on Amaya, who simply didn’t play a ton in 2025. In fact, Amaya’s 96 at-bats were the lowest total of any of his three seasons in the big leagues so far. Take the small sample size with a grain of salt, but his strikeout rate (21.4%), whiff rate (26.0%) and chase rate (36.8%) all left much to be desired in that time. The pop is clearly there. Now, it comes down to pitch identification and plate discipline, something that catchers of all people should have an advantage in. Given that those skills develop with more repetitions, it's a problem that Amaya's injury history is growing concerningly long when factoring in his time in the minors.

Ballesteros, on the other hand, gets to swing freely as the projected starting designated hitter. When a 22-year-old is being projected to play at DH, though, that should tell you all you need to know about their defensive skills.

The Bottom Line

There’s a very clear changing of the guard happening here. With Kelly’s short-term contract nearing its end, it’ll be up to Amaya and Ballesteros/a prospect to slide up a spot in the team’s depth chart. Their power could be the calling card for a lineup that had to say goodbye to Kyle Tucker (22 home runs in 2025) after just one season.

If both of these up-and-comers are hits? Chicago may have its answer for the foreseeable future, especially if they can find a veteran replacement for Kelly to pair with Amaya. Those are longer-term problems, though. For 2026, the Cubs are well positioned to run out a competent group of backstops.