Jump to content
North Side Baseball

PVG

Old-Timey Member
  • Posts

    30
  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Profiles

Chicago Cubs Videos

Chicago Cubs Trade & Free Agent Rumors

2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospect Rankings

Chicago Cubs News, Rumors & Analysis

2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Chicago Cubs Fan Guides & Resources

2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Blogs

Events

Forums

Store

Gallery

Everything posted by PVG

  1. Matt, this post is very much over the top. There have been days as hot as yesterday (or today) 20, 40 and 60 years ago. Some solutions for umpires would be to have two home plate umpires one for the first half of a game and one for the second half. There could also be 4 base umpires - with one rotating out each inning. I don't think that anyone is predicting that baseball will be unplayable outside in the 20 years - or even 50 years in Chicago - where did you get that from? More night games and more shade would help the fan experience. A lot of people love indoor baseball. I believe the Astros attendance is something like 32,000 per game - some years even better - when the team is more competitive. It's not clear at all what the solution to global warming might be. Estimates are that if the US (13% of global emissions) would cease all emissions tomorrow it would affect the change in global temps by 0.2 degrees C by 2100. Probably tech solutions will be necessary - large increase in cheap energy (nuclear) which might make carbon capture economical and solar engineering (the star wars - outer space kind) as a temporary measure.. Back to baseball - I think the real problem facing baseball is the increase in injuries, esp to pitchers - see https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/25460405-mlb-pitching-injuries/ Stays on the IL have doubled since 2012. Growing up a few years ago - I would watch Fergie Jenkins, Kenny Holtzman, Bill Hands, Milt Pappas take the mound every 4 days -they overlapped with Rick Reuschel - and complete games were a regular feature. And those pitchers pitched for years. Now we have an epidemic of injuries and it seems that your favorite pitcher is always on the IL. I hope the baseball minds can come up with some solutions. Also will Matt Shaw ever be a hitter?
  2. Let me tell you where I'm coming from. In my very large organization, we have a DEI office which promotes a DEI admissions policy This policy gives extra weight to students from certain races, either directly or through proxy. In general these students do not meet the same academic entry standards as the students who were not granted this extra admissions "bonus". And in general, these students end up performing less well across all student outcome metrics.. And the differences are not minor - there's a really major gap. And there is definitely a cohort of students who were not granted admission and who in general, would have performed better than these students.. So I see DEI as a process to not only open doors but an attempt to advantage individuals and groups who had been disadvantaged/discriminated against in the past. And that's why I don't consider JR a DEI hire. He was clearly more talented and capable than many of the players already on the Dodgers. He had been directly denied this opportunity - he didn't need the bonus points, just someone to open the doors - I think that's different from the situation I described. If you want to continue the discussion I'm happy to do so - it's really not necessary to throw brickbats my way.
  3. Dear Matt, I don't know that this is a good space for you to promote your political views. Furthermore, I think it would be easy to push back on many of your points. And why abandon statistics when trying to make your argument? On top of that, the essay gives off the vibe (that I think that I hear from some liberals) that not only are you wrong if you disagree with me, but you are also morally corrupt. So I guess in this case - you said would you meant. That being said, I think it's clearly incorrect and even misleading to describe Jackie Robinson as a DEI hire. In the DEI movement there are a lot of beautiful words, and a lot of frankly, incomprehensible words. However, I think the general understanding of a DEI hire or a person that matriculates thru a DEI process, is someone who has inferior credentials and is promoted over someone more qualified due to some characteristic such as race, gender, sexual orientation, etc. But as you said, and was self-evident, JR had superior credentials and was being excluded due to his race. He does not fit the definition of a DEI hire. Just the opposite really, Those who promote a "color-blind" protocol would insist that he be hired.
  4. So how does a guy like Nico improve? Can he do it without adding power - a la Tony Gwynn, and all those famous singles hitters of yesteryear?
  5. Sept. 1 ... the kind of bullpen catalyst Counsell specializes in developing and empowering. ... he's a walking affirmation of the staying power of Counsell's capacity for turning rookies into relief aces. ...Hodge's breakout season is a testament to the value of their manager, Hi Matt, I've been reading your articles for several months now - and I'd like to get your overall evaluation. Besides the two pitchers you mentioned in this article - Hader and Williams, what are the other rookies that Counsell turned "into relief aces"? I'm not being sarcastic , I just don't follow baseball nearly as closely as most on this site - so I truly don't know. Thanks. If a coach or manager has this kind of ability - wouldn't he be worth even more than the $40M that the Cubs are paying him? Hader has been paid $44M over the last 3 years and Williams $7M this year. So, one might say that Counsell has developed more than $50M of pitching value via these two pitchers alone. Are there other managers/coaches who can do this? Are there others who can do similar things for starting pitchers, hitters? Who are they? Assuming all this is true, it seems inconsistent with some of your previous articles - 1) perhaps Counsell is past his prime 2) Counsell is not responsible for the future performance of the bullpen 3) Counsell is responsible for the "failed" Morel experiment 4) Counsell's challenge process is inferior How do we square all this? Is Counsell invaluable - or when considering his deficiencies is he merely human :) ?
×
×
  • Create New...