I'm not a doctor and i don't have any inside info on Nomar, but I think ruling him out for the year is a little premature and flies in the face of the evidence we have. For one thing, Piazza's injury occured at the end of May. Nomar's was almost exactly one month earlier at the end of April. Secon, Piazza didn't have surgery while Nomar did. This was to clean up the area around the tendon, not to fix the tendon and was done to make the healing process better. For Piazza's injury they said 4-6 weeks but one doctor said a minimum of 8 weeks. For Nomar they said 2-3 months. Three months is July 20th. I don't think it's impossible, given Dusty's optimism, that he is slightly ahead of schedule. Which makes July 14th, first game after the AS break, reasonable. However, it is interesting that July 20th is the date of our next Cardinal series. How would that be for a pick-me-up if Nomar was back. Again, I don't claim to have any more information. But I don't think comparing him to Piazza is the way to go. Even if we did, the fact that Piazza's injury occured a month after Nomar's, and that Piazza came back in Septemeber, would mean at the very least we could expect Nomar in early August given your rationale.