That's what a callup for an injured player is, a kick the tires situation. I don't think people are guaranteeing superstardom, rather they are expressing excitement to see a very talented player on the team. I hear the under-tone of "boy, hell come up and show himself as a wunderkind and be starting cf by the end of the month" I remember Bobby Hill and the excitement generated by his call up. I hope everyone is right and he is a great hitter and fielder. Pie is not Bobby Hill. Seriously, Pie was going to be recalled at some point. At the very least, he can play tremendous defense. If he is able to add anything on offense it is a plus; I'm sure there will be an adjustment period.