Neifi is ok as a sub, but I don't there is any other team in baseball that would be comfortable with him as a starter. Cedeno on the other hand, could either be really good or could be really bad. The choice comes down to whether or not you go with proven "averageness"(Neifi's career stats are .270-.301-.380). And actually, those stats aren't even average for a shortstop, they are just plain bad. The only conclusion that one can come to is that Neifi has compromising photos of Dusty Baker hidden away in a safe somewhere, because there isn't any rational reason why he should even be considered as a starter.