I say he gets one more chance next year, but we start the season with 5 other bona fide starters. If he stays healthy, we trade someone come July. If the shoulder/mechanics get wonky again, we see if he can become the next John Smoltz. As Smoltzie has shown, you CAN do the starter role again after being in the pen for a long time. I couldnt agree more. Next year he starts, and if his mechanics arent changed/ his shoulder acts up, THEN you put him in the pen. However, without him as a successful and healthy starter, I dont see this team going anywhere next year.