Pie is still young, and there is no reason to believe his career is over or mismanaged to minutia. What surprises me is so that so many people around here are surprised by this move. Hendry and Piniella have repeatedly stated a desire to find a left-handed HR potential to plug in the 5-spot. Pie, even is if he excels in his limited role so far, doesn't fit the bill for this season (emphasis on this season). It is debatable, obviously, whether or not Edmonds fits the bill, but clearly management feels he has a better shot this year than Pie at satisfying the need. I don't see this as being about approval or disapproval of Pie's production. It's about the 2008 lineup puzzle that Piniella and Hendry obsess over. They want that lefty HR potential in the middle. Switching gears: should Edmonds get in the lineup and produce at all, it's likely Fukudome finally moves up to 2-spot and Theriot down to the 8-spot, which means we might see Lee and Ramirez hitting in the first inning with Fukudome on about 40% of the time all season long. I like that quite a bit. So to get a #5 hitter with hr power, they signed an old guy with 1 hr in 90 ABs this season and 12 in 365 last season. That's a miserable failure at procuring the desired player type. He went from 1 hr every 11 abs in 2004 to 1 every 17 to 18 to 30 to 90 (ok, last data point is weak, but I'm keeping it). This is a guy who would be lucky to hit 15 hr if he played a whole season.