I can appreciate the point you are attempting to make, but you whiff big time on this. Gathright and Bynum might have been the same type players, but they weren't anywhere near as productive as Campana during their stints with the Cubs to make fans love them. Heck, Bynum had fewer stolen bases his entire career than Campana did last year. Yep. Bynum had 8 SB with the Cubs. Gathright had one. Gathright had one of the most pathetic lines in recent Cub history, now that I look. I guess I forgot all 15 of his PAs. He got on base four times and was CS twice.