Even if the experience tells you definitively that you are playing one of the weakest defensive catchers in the league? I'm not with you [-( This year Barrett did worse than Kendall and I didn't see too many people yell about that and Barrett may be worse defensively than Kendall too. the switch-a-roo so many have done on the need for defense out of catcher has been rather nauseating. the benefit of defense out of a catcher was one of the most intense debates on this board in May, June, and July. Hendry acquires a catcher who's not too handy with the glove and arm, and suddenly there is no debate. suddenly everyone seems to agree that we need good defense out of our catcher. For the millionth time, it's a matter of degrees. Barrett was below average in most defensive aspects and occasionally made some dumb decisions. He was also one of the best offensive catchers in baseball. Kendall is physically incapable of throwing anyone, anyone, out on the basepaths, and at his best he provides plus OBP with zero XBH. They are different situations. oh puh-leez. saying Kendall is worse than Barrett at defense to any degree is garbage. maybe he's slightly worse, but I doubt that. Barrett's about as bad as it gets. Barrett was below average in most defensive aspects...the past couple of years. this year he was just horrendous. believe me, as I was one who defended Barrett's defensive abilities the past couple years, but after middle May 2007, I could not longer continue to do so. and Barrett WAS one of the best offensive catchers in baseball. now suddenly we want to diminish the importance of OBP over SLG, where as in any other context you and any of the other switch a roos would argue the opposite. no context was needed, and they are not different situations. this went from a board ranting that we traded for Rob Bowen and had Koyie Hill because defense out of a catcher was over-rated (despite Barrett continuing to stink it up offensively in SD), to the board ranting about how horrible Kendall was at defense the instant he was acquired. it was literally overnight that many had a change of opinion on the importance of defense out of a catcher. the very night that Kendall played his first game, many who previously went on and on about the lack of importance out of catcher's defense, who only weeks earlier were excusing Barrett for not catching the four hopper from rightfield, were suddenly blaming the loss of that game on catcher's defense. I want Soto to be starting as bad as anyone, but let's stop reinventing history in order to make the point.